Why I don’t believe people are the weakest link
By Barbara van Bebber, Founder of Shannon Digital Trust
For years, I’ve heard people described as the weakest link in cybersecurity.
While I understand where that statement comes from, I’ve never been entirely comfortable with it.
Not because people don’t make mistakes. We all do.
But because the phrase often suggests that security failures happen because people didn’t pay enough attention, didn’t know enough or simply made the wrong decision.
In my experience, the reality is usually more complex.
People make decisions within the environments we create for them. They work under pressure, manage competing priorities, adopt new technologies and try to get their jobs done efficiently.
When security measures are difficult to understand, difficult to follow or disconnected from everyday work, even well-intentioned people can struggle.
That doesn’t make them the weakest link.
It means we need to look beyond the individual.
When I look at a security challenge, I don’t just ask:
“What did the person do?”
I also ask:
Did the technology support them, or work against them?
Were our policies and controls realistic for how people actually work?
What made the secure choice the harder choice, in that moment?
Where did the process break down before the person was ever involved?
These aren’t easier questions to answer. They ask us to examine our own systems and decisions, rather than someone else’s mistake. But they’re the questions that actually lead to better security.
When we understand the environment someone was working in, we can fix the environment — not just remind people to be more careful.
That’s the shift I try to bring to every organisation I work with: from blaming the person to understanding the system around them. People aren’t the weakest link. They’re the ones who show us, every day, where our systems still need to get stronger.
If this is how you’d like to think about security in your organisation, let’s talk.